Strafrechtelijke causaliteit. De redelijke toerekening vergeleken met het privaatrecht
PhD ceremony: Mr. E.M. Witjens, 16.15 uur, Academiegebouw, Broerstraat 5, Groningen
Title: Strafrechtelijke causaliteit. De redelijke toerekening vergeleken met het privaatrecht
Promotor(s): prof. G. Knigge, prof. M.H. Wissink
Faculty: Law
The connection between cause and effect, in other words: the causal link, isn’t a straightforward affair for jurists. This is because of the normative approach that both Criminal and Civil Law impose upon it. To factually cause an effect, an empirical finding, differs from causing an effect in the legal sense of the word.
The theories that were devised in the law over the course of time have been unable to fully explain the difference with empirical causation. Because these theories are, for the most part, common to Criminal and Civil Law, the two areas were subjected tocomprehensive study and a fundamental comparison was made.
It was found that the underlying principle of causation in the law, according to which a necessary condition for an effect to occur is classified as a cause if without it the effect would fail to materialize (the so-called ‘condicio sine qua non’ test), does not sit well with (empirical) reality. A decision on empirical causation always implies a certain amount of uncertainty. The c.s.q.n. test conceals this. Other theories also bring about problems in their application.
This bolstered the notion that a new approach for Criminal Causation should be devised. The understanding of the issue, accumulated while researching, made clear that the current system can be of no use anymore. The fundamental revision of causation in the law that has been devised in this thesis, lays a stronger foundation for the decision about causality and makes it possible to gain insight into this issue.
Last modified: | 13 March 2020 01.09 a.m. |
More news
-
11 July 2025
Alette Smeulers ontrafelt het kwaad: ‘Gewone mensen, extreme daden’
Internationale misdrijven als genocide, oorlogsmisdaden en misdaden tegen de menselijkheid roepen al decennia vragen op: hoe kunnen mensen hiertoe in staat zijn? Wat bezielt hen? En hoe kunnen we dit begrijpen zonder te vervallen in simplificaties...
-
09 July 2025
Faculteit Rechtsgeleerdheid opent deuren tijdens Rondje Rechtsstaat
Op zaterdagmiddag 13 september neemt de Faculteit Rechtsgeleerdheid deel aan Rondje Rechtsstaat, onderdeel van de landelijke Week van de Rechtsstaat. Tussen 13.00 en 16.00 uur is iedereen welkom in het Rölinggebouw om meer te ontdekken over de...
-
07 July 2025
Laura Peters appointed Knight in the Order of the Star of Italy
Dr Laura Peters, Associate Professor of Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure at our faculty, has been appointed Cavaliere dell’Ordine della Stella d’Italia (Knight in the Order of the Star of Italy). The honour was conferred on 4 July on behalf of...